McCarthy Tire Service

William Titus a year ago

Scheduled an alignment on my car a week ahead. They had me on the list and took me as soon as I got there. The tech did a fantastic job with my alignment and the price was absolutely fair for the work needed. Highly recommend them for alignments.

Isaac Saqib 2 years ago

Went to this place expecting to see Jason and the guys from Roli but instead was greeted by an older dry attitude gentlemen. Dropped my car to fix a small leak in one tire - had to call them to check on pickup when usually I would get a call as soon as the job is done - upon arrival I find a spare on my car after being told the job was done. After speaking to the older dry attitude gentleman, he proceeds to tell me I need to change all 4 tires cause of varying issues - I told him can he just change the one if it's bad and he says he doesn't even know the size? You can literally walk outside and look at the size. On top of this, he had the audacity to charge me to do something I didn't even want and have a bad attitude the entire time. Sad to say I will never be returning to what was once a great tire shop and a gem in the farmingdale community.

Ashley Rivera 7 years ago

Recently went to Roli to get some much needed maintenance (tires, brakes, oil change) done on my car & the entire experience was wonderful. Rich, Jason & the entire team we're extremely attentive and made sure to go over with me everything the car needed and answer all of my questions! I've gotten these services done at other places and always felt like I was getting either ripped off or that the person helping me didn't want to be explaining anything at all; but at Roli it was the exact opposite! They've officially won me over and I won't be going anywhere else for my car needs!!

Arthur Houde 9 years ago

I was the first car there on a weekday morning. Had a low tire pressure warning light on. Was told the nail went thru the sidewall and that the tire needed replacing. No one showed me the damage. Charged me $162 for an average Cooper tire. The shop owner seemed nice and knowledgeable. Went outside after waiting well over an hour to find the tech scratched my rim and didn't put the valve stem cap back on. There were greasy hand prints all over the rim. I was so annoyed I just left and will never go back! They seem like the kind of place that talks a good deal and maybe the owner is a good guy but, his staff is clearly incompetent and the shop is very overpriced. I sense they took advantage of the situation knowing I was stranded at their mercy.

Daniel Bemiss 10 years ago

Great deal on two hard to find tires for my Mazda CX-7 that are only made by Bridgestone tires. They gave the best quote over the phone before I went to the shop then installed the two new tires and rotated the two old tires to the front so the new tires were correctly installed on the back. Huge waiting room with TV and coffee made the wait seem like it flew by. Sales reps were very nice and helpful. Took home a bunch of business cards to share with family and friends. Wish every business was as amazing as Roli Tires! Only bad feedback is they need a big sign at the street to show where the business is. It was hard to find the right place to park because they have three different buildings. Will definitely be back though!